
I don’t think I can do a proper review of these books. a) I’ve left it too late since I read them and b) I just enjoyed them so much, I’d rather not dissect them. I don’t think they are perfect, but they are very good. Mostly I wanted to post about them so I’d remember, and to encourage everyone else to pick them up. The books are set on another planet, where all men can hear each others’ ‘Noise’, or thoughts. Women can hear thoughts, but don’t project them, and even animals ‘speak’, though with limited vocabulary.
The Knife of Never Letting Go
Todd Hewitt is about to become a man. He’s the last boy in Prentisstown, a place with no women as they were all killed, so Todd has been told, by a war with the indigenous species, The Spackle. One day Todd comes across a hole in the Noise that doesn’t make sense, and he is forced to flee Prentisstown, followed by the Mayor and a growing army. The strange hole in the noise turns out to be Viola Eade, a young girl who has crash landed on the planet in a scout ship, and more settlers are coming. Todd and Viola team up in the hopes of getting to the town of Haven, to warn them of the coming army, and to contact Viola’s ships.
This book is told solely from Todd’s point of view. Some of my favourite bits of the story involve Manchee, Todd’s dog, who irritates Todd no end, but who is a wonderful source of humour.
The Ask and the Answer
Todd and Viola are separated, and the Mayor has named himself President of New World. Todd is forced to work among the Spackle, as their jailer, while Viola recuperates in a house of healing, under the watch of Mistress Coyle. As the Mayor takes over, he separates the women and keeps them locked up, and the town doesn’t fight back. The women, led by Mistress Coyle, escape, with Viola among them, and begin a bombing campaign against the town. Todd grows closer to the Mayor, and begins learning to control his own Noise, and use it as a weapon. In the end, it’s not just the Mayor they have to worry about, as an entire Spackle army is on approach.
I enjoyed this even more than the first one, although it is especially harrowing at times. My heart was breaking. I just loved Todd and Viola, even though they weren’t together very much. The only problem I had with this one, and the books in general, is the Mayor. Why is he like he is? Is he just insane and power mad? Does he just want war? I don’t really get his motives other than there needs to be a bad guy. Also, how many times did I want them to just shoot him? They have so many opportunities but end up just standing around arguing. It felt a little long in that regard, like they were having the same conversation over and over. But, that’s my only issue. It’s an extremely fast, enjoyable read. This one is written from the point of view of both Todd and Viola, and I loved being able to get inside her head as well.
Monsters of Men
Todd and Viola are separated again as they prepare for battle on three fronts. There’s the Mayor who wants complete control, the Answer who want to defeat the Mayor (and both want to be in control when the settlers arrive), and the Spackle. Todd and Viola are in the middle, especially Viola, who wants to stop Mistress Coyle from ruining any chance of peace with the Spackle, but who also has Todd’s welfare to think of. And there’s Todd, who is changing by being around the Mayor…
Those are just snapshots of the main plots of the books, there’s so much more going on. The series has some heavy themes, and there’s loss and redemption, the cost of war – on both a personal and global level – and of course there is love. Todd and Viola’s love for each other is what keeps them going, even when apart for long stretches, and the belief they have in each other, of their inherent goodness. It is this that will lead to a change on New World.
Tags: chaos walking trilogy